Robert Cole Rebuts John Yoo

Esquire, May 13, by John H. Richardson
http://www.esquire.com/features/john-yoo-0608

“Torture violates the very premise of the legal system itself, that there is something irreducible and inviolable about every person,” says Yoo’s fellow Berkeley law professor Robert H. Cole. “You can’t write a memo about it the way you would write about snowmobiling in Yosemite.”

John Yoo Defends Policy of Harsh Interrogations

Esquire, May 13, by John H. Richardson
http://www.esquire.com/features/john-yoo-0608

But those harsh interrogation techniques migrated straight to Iraq. What about that? “That was definitely not permitted under the decision-making level I was at,” Yoo says. “It was clearly not. The Geneva Conventions fully applied in Iraq…. In World War II, we interned people, tens of thousands of citizens. We tried citizens who were enemy spies under military commissions which had no procedures at all…. We dropped a nuclear weapon on Japan. Waterboarding we think is torture, but it happened to three people. The scale of magnitude is different.”

Eric Talley Supports Congressional Inquiry into Milberg Weiss’ Illegal Conduct

San Francisco Daily Journal, May 12, by Lawrence Hurley
http://www.dailyjournal.com

Congressional action couldn’t do any harm, Talley suggested. “Shining a light on the practice will act as a deterrent,” he said. Why prosecutors didn’t act sooner in pursuing Milberg Weiss is another key question. “That’s where we want to be spending a lot of our time,” Talley said. “Why wasn’t the Justice Department able to uncover this evidence for such a long period of time?”

Elisabeth Semel Says Supreme Court Ruling on Lethal Injection Invites Legal Challenges

National Law Journal, May 12, by Elisabeth Semel
http://www.law.com/jsp/nlj/PubArticleNLJ.jsp?id=1202421171423

“Politicians like Schwarzenegger have grabbed hold of Baze, proclaimed that it has ended challenges to lethal injection and hope to ride it through a wave of soon-to-be-scheduled executions. Whether they are successful depends on whether lower courts heed, or ignore, the complexities of the court’s seven opinions.”

Robert MacCoun Corrects News Report on Medical Marijuana

The Daily Californian, May 6, by Robert MacCoun
http://www.dailycal.org/article/101605/letters_to_the_editor

Mayor Bates’ letter to the federal government may have been right on the merits, and worth writing for that reason, but I would be quite surprised if it helped to influence federal policy toward medical marijuana dispensaries. A letter from Berkeley in favor of medical marijuana simply plays to this administration’s stereotyped “culture wars” framing of the issue.

Robert MacCoun Says Politicians Ignore Benefits of Insite, Canada’s Safe-Injection Facility

The Globe and Mail, May 2, by André Picard
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20080502.wdrug02/BNStory/National/home

Dr. MacCoun said that Mr. Clement’s critique of Insite  “Do safe injection sites contribute to lowering drug use and fighting addiction?”  misses the point of harm reduction. He said the project is designed to minimize the harm IV drugs users do to themselves and others, something a law-and-order approach cannot achieve.

The Globe and Mail Editorial, May 5
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20080505.weinsite05/BNStory/specialComment/home?cid=al_gam_mostemail

“Taking the facts as presented, a well-executed piece of policy research on a promising innovation was discontinued for unstated but blatant political reasons.”